Score: 10

"Well done :)"

submission: Royal Assassin

date: 14 hours ago

Just out of curiosity, how much of the piano in this was played by hand? Also, great job on this. I muck around a lot on an older copy of Reason, but I could never do anything close to this :P

Score: 2

"Eh."

submission: popo (earbleed contest)

date: 15 hours ago

This is one of those songs that would be better to eat after eating some "magic mushrooms."

Score: 8

"In response"

submission: Half Baked Monkey

date: July 3, 2008

In reply to that dude's review
I
V

It sounds like a heavily reverbed guitar, or a heavily distorted piano, or maybe a combination of the two.

Score: 10

"Quite Nice."

submission: This is Halloween (piano)

date: June 2, 2008

I have a question for you: Is this single track or multi track? If it is multi track, how many tacks? If this is a single track, you have ungodly piano skills...

Score: 9

"Quite Nice"

submission: Mylifeuncut - It

date: May 29, 2008

I really enjoyed this, but I think that you should have cut out the empty space between 1:11 and 1:19. I especially liked how you let the piano on strings "hang" at the 40 second mark. Very nicely done, I hope to see more good work from you :)

Score: 5

"Oh Gawds"

submission: Do Not Click Here!

date: May 28, 2008

Please, please please pleeeeeeeease don't make another song like this. Seriously, I value my non-bleeding ears *very* highly. You get two points for creativity and another 3 complementary spoof points, then another because you named one of them "Dying Jake." But you lose one because you named another one of them "Doodles."

Score: 10

"Stunning."

submission: Car add commercial

date: May 21, 2008

This sounds so much like Eric Bachmann's score for Short Careers: Ball of Wax. It has perfect instrumentation, great melodies, soothing harmonies, and loops very well! This deserves it's place of best classical song!

Score: 10

"This is amazing!"

submission: Afternoon Breeze

date: May 21, 2008

I've been looking through the classical submissions and I've been quite shocked at some of the piano pieces. This has got to be one of the best, especially if you were playing from memory. As for myself, I always play from memory, I never even learned sheet music. But this, this would be far beyond my skills. You might want to think of investing in a program like Reason or FL Studio, because you would be able to record through midi and fix your mistakes, as well as add more tracks. 5/5

Score: 9

"Wonderful, but you should change the drums,"

submission: Currick

date: May 21, 2008

Very good melody, but I think that you should change the instrumentation a bit, especially the drums. Also, a little bit of distortion is present when the strings hit high notes. I'm giving this a 4/5, it's great but I'm leaving a little room for improvement.

Score: 10

"Absolutely Stunning."

submission: Nocturne in D min "Dear Nicky"

date: May 20, 2008

Two questions.
1. Did you write this?
2. Is this a single unaltered track, played by hand?

If the answers to those are yes, then I am amazed. It's such a beautiful, calming song. And it's played magnificently as well. This deserves it's position as highest rated classical song on the portal. Excellent work.